Director of Public Prosecutions v Hanley [2019] IECA 358 (14 November 2019)

BAILII is celebrating 24 years of free online access to the law! Would you consider making a contribution?
No donation is too small. If every visitor before 31 December gives just £1, it will have a significant impact on BAILII's ability to continue providing free access to the law.
Thank you very much for your support!

JUDGMENT (Ex tempore) of the Court delivered on the 14th day of November 2019 by

1. This is an appeal against severity of sentence. The sentence under appeal is one of five

years imprisonment with the final two years of the sentence suspended that was imposed

in the Dublin Circuit Criminal Court on 29th March 2019 in respect of a count of robbery.

On that occasion, a s. 3 assault charge was taken into consideration.

2. The sentencing Court was concerned with events that occurred on 23rd November 2017.

On that occasion, the injured party, a 65-year old man, had visited a bookies shop on

Parnell Street, Dublin, in order to collect winnings. He travelled in the direction of

Mountjoy Square and was attacked at Gardiner Lane. He was punched to the face and

knocked to the ground. During the course of the robbery, the appellant threatened him,

saying he had a knife, and restrained him by standing on his leg. The injured party

sustained a broken leg which required surgery, there were some complications thereafter

and physiotherapy was required. It was accepted that the appellant had not set out to

break the leg of his victim. The victim also suffered a broken tooth and cuts, grazes and

3. The appellant was identified from CCTV footage and subsequently arrested, interviewed

and eventually charged. He entered a plea of guilty at the first mention date, it was

4. In terms of the appellant’s background and personal circumstances, he was 54 years of

age at the time of the sentence hearing. He experienced significant health issues. He was

suffering from lung cancer and treatment to date had involved chemotherapy and the

removal of the lung. While the appellant had previous convictions, all had been dealt with

summarily and none involved violence. In all, 22 previous convictions were recorded, of

which six were for theft. The appellant brought a sum of €2,000 to Court to offer to the

injured party, but that was not an offer of interest to the injured party.

5. The judge’s approach to sentence was to identify a headline sentence of eight years.

Having regard to the mitigating factors present, she reduced that sentence by three years

and therefore imposed a sentence of five years imprisonment, but then a further two

years of that sentence were then suspended owning to the serious health issues faced by

6. On behalf of the appellant, it is said that the judge erred in nominating a headline

sentence at the midrange and further erred by failing to adequately allow for the

significant mitigating and extenuating personal circumstances advanced on behalf of the

appellant. It is fair to say that the emphasis has been very much on the criticisms of the

7. In the Court’s view, the headline sentence of eight years could be regarded as having

been at the higher end of the available range, but whatever about that, the ultimate

sentence of three years to be served could not be seen as severe, indeed, quite the

contrary. This was a case where violence was deployed and injuries inflicted.

8. In those circumstances, had a somewhat more severe sentence been imposed, we might

well have been prepared to uphold it. We are quite satisfied that the sentence could not

be regarded as so excessively severe as to amount to an error in principle. We must,

therefore, dismiss the appeal.

Result: Dismiss

	[Home] [Databases] [World Law] [Multidatabase Search] [Help] [Feedback]
	Irish Court of Appeal
You are here: BAILII >> Databases >> Irish Court of Appeal >> Director of Public Prosecutions v Hanley [2019] IECA 358 (14 November 2019) URL: http://www.bailii.org/ie/cases/IECA/2019/2019IECA358.html Cite as: [2019] IECA 358

Irish Court of Appeal